Local Search Site Search
Home Delivery
  • Home
  • Today's Globe
  • News
  • Your Town
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • A&E
  • Things to do
  • Travel
  • Cars
  • Jobs
  • Real Estate
 
< Back to front page Text size – +

Who wants their boss making decisions for them about birth control?

Print | Comments () Posted by Carol Rose, On Liberty  February 16, 2012 10:37 AM
  • Tweet
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

E-mail this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

ACLU of Massachusetts communications director Christopher Ott wrote this guest blog.

Senator Scott Brown would presumably never support legislation allowing a restaurant owner to refuse service to members of a specific race--and rightly so. We've made it unlawful for business owners to impose views like this on their customers or the communities where they do business.

Senator Brown would also never support legislation making it legal for a business owner to refuse to hire people of another religious faith. Except for ministerial-type positions, we've passed laws to prevent that kind of discrimination too.

That's what makes it confusing--and alarming--that Senator Brown now supports legislation that would allow employers to impose their beliefs on employees. Senator Brown has cosponsored an extreme measure known as the Blunt Amendment, which would allow any employer to deny coverage for any health care service--not just contraception, but things like HIV testing, cervical cancer, fertility treatment, genetic testing, and more--by citing "religious beliefs or moral convictions."

We need to tell Senator Brown that no one's boss should be making decisions about employees' use of birth control, or other private health matters.

Over the past couple of weeks, religious groups have claimed that there is a "war on religion" because the federal Affordable Care Act would require health insurance plans for employees to cover, without cost, certain preventive health care (including contraception) in their plans. But this is hardly a "war on religion."

Already in Massachusetts, religious-affiliated hospitals are not exempt from having to provide emergency contraception to rape victims at hospital emergency rooms, and have also been required to cover contraception in employee health plans if other prescriptions are covered.

Scott Brown, as a state lawmaker, voted for the final versions of the legislation that made that law. Why has he changed his views now?

Additionally, many of today's opponents of offering these plans are large businesses, such as hospitals or universities that serve the public and hire employees regardless of religion, and they often receive taxpayer dollars for their work. There is no reason to allow them to impose religious views on their employees.

In response to the demand that women's health care be sacrificed, the Obama administration fortunately offered a smart, reasonable compromise, which ensures respect for true religious freedom and prevents these employers from imposing their views on others.

The compromise is that religious employers who object to birth control don't have to specifically include it in their employee health plans--but the insurance companies will have to make sure it is provided anyway. And for those concerned about cost, insurance companies are likely to save money, since the Pill and other contraceptives are much less expensive than unplanned pregnancies.

Practically speaking, this means that employees get coverage for birth control regardless of what their employers think--and that's exactly how it should be. Religious liberty is a personal thing, and it certainly doesn't mean what Senator Brown and others are essentially saying it should: the ability to impose religious convictions on others.

In this case, Senator Brown and others, such as the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, are hardly acting as defenders of religious liberty. In reality, they're simply trying to impose their views on others, and to deny religious liberty to individuals who just want to exercise their own religious or moral judgment in personal matters that are now--literally, thanks to the Obama move--none of their employer's business.

This blog is not written or edited by Boston.com or the Boston Globe.
The author is solely responsible for the content.
  • Tweet
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

  • Previous Story
    Komen and Planned Parenthood: keep politics out of decisions on women's health
  • Front Page
  • Next Story
    It’s time for Senator Scott Brown to admit to a mistake.

LOG IN TO COMMENT

Sorry, we could not find your e-mail or password.
Please try again, or click here to retrieve your password.
Existing users
*E-mail:
*Password:
*Screen name:
(* fields are required)
Login
Forgot your password?
New users
Please take a minute to register. After you register and pick a screen name, you can publish your comments everywhere on the site. Posting Policy.

Register


TRUSTe Certified Privacy

Your comment is subject to the rules of our Posting Policy
This comment may appear on your public profile. Public Profile FAQ

About the author

Carol Rose is executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts. A lawyer and journalist, Carol has spent her career working for and writing about human rights and civil liberties, both in the United States and abroad. More »

Recent blog posts

  • It’s time for Senator Scott Brown to admit to a mistake.
  • Who wants their boss making decisions for them about birth control?
  • Komen and Planned Parenthood: keep politics out of decisions on women's health
  • The silent guest at the State of the Union
  • Victory! Government must get a warrant to use GPS tracking devices on our cars.

More community voices

24 Hour Workday

By

Kara Baskin

  • Am I Mom Enough? A Motherhood Wish List...

After the Storm

By

UMass journalists

  • State officials believe forests should stay 'untouched' in torn...

BostoNite

By Rachel Kossman
  • Grab an Uber...

Boston Real Estate Now

By

Scott Von Voorhis and Rona Fischman

  • Is a musician persona non grata?...

Boston Spirit

By

David Zimmerman and Jim Lopata

  • Pride: 40 Years of Protest & Celebration: New LGBT Exhibition O...

Child Caring

By

Barbara Meltz

  • Kids call her son "gay"...

Child in Mind

By Claudia M. Gold, M.D.
  • Giving Troubled Young Children a Voice

Chow Down Beantown

By Jacki Morisi and Michelle Zippelli
  • Making Mozzarella at Dave's Fresh Pasta

Consumer Alert

By Mitch Lipka
  • Be leery of duct cleaning deals...

Creative Type

By Delia Cabe
  • How green is your ebook?

Crime & Punishment

By James Alan Fox
  • Fatal flaws in biolab report

Culture Club

By Kara Miller
  • Excitement? Not for Mitt.

Dollar for Dollar

By Christine Dunn
  • At what age do you expect to retire? Gallup poll finds most peo...

Economy & Equity

By Barry Bluestone
  • Senior Discounts: A Gift for the Rich

The E Word

By

Peter Post

  • When an Online Relationship Leads to a First Date—Who Pays?

Fantasy Fools

By

Ladd Biro

  • My first mock draft of the 2012 season

Fiftyshift

By BJ Roche
  • Our number's up: saving for retirement when you can't afford to retire

Gatekeeper

By Mark Leccese
  • Candidates don’t have to answer every reporter’s question

Health Stew

By John McDonough
  • "Alfalfa to Ivy": Memoir of a Harvard Medical School Dean

Hub Arts

By Joel Brown
  • Zombie apocalypse needs backers

The Hyphenated Life

By

Francie Latour

  • Jay-Z In the Range

Inbound Sounds

By Jonathan Donaldson
  • Musical t-shirts with Battle House – at Midway Cafe 5/19...

In Practice

By

Dr. Suzanne Koven

  • Weight Loss Is Math, Sort Of

Joyschtick

By Aaron Price
  • A review of 'Zombies, Run!'

Less Is More

By Garrett Quinn
  • Bob Barr endorses Mitt Romney

MD Mama

By Dr. Claire McCarthy
  • Scary statistics about teens and heart disease that everyone should know

Nutrition and You!

By Joan Salge Blake
  • How to avoid BBQ blunders

Obnoxious Boston Fan

By

Obnoxious Boston Fan

  • Boston Powers, Stephen A. Smith close stellar year in SNL sports

On Liberty

By Carol Rose
  • “Show me your papers” comes to Massachusetts...

Pack Up

By Melanie Nayer
  • Dramatic Designs: Mandarin Oriental New York's elliptical lobby...

Rock The Schoolhouse

By Jim Stergios
  • Decision time on extended learning

Short White Coat

By

Dr. Ishani Ganguli

  • To resuscitate or not to resuscitate: is that the right question?

Small Business Blog

By Jason Keith
  • It's an image heavy world, just ask Instagram...

The Next Great Generation

By TNGG Boston Staff
  • Innovative internships: Design...

Weather Wisdom

By David Epstein
  • First tropical storm of season forms in Atlantic
Get updates
My Yahoo
RSS Feed
  • Learn about RSS
archives

Browse this blog

by category

INside Boston.com

  • C's dancers workshop
    C's dancers workshop
    Prospective Celtics dancers were put through the paces
  • Billboard Music Awards
    Taylor Swift
    Taylor Swift and more stars at the Billboard Music Awards
  • Top 10 cities to retire
    Top 10 cities to retire
    San Francisco lures retirees with its natural beauty
  • Best and worst dressed
    Best and worst dressed
    Diane Kruger's mint green gown was a hit at Cannes
  • Plus...
    • Blogs
    • |
    • Crossword
    • |
    • Comics
    • |
    • Horoscopes
    • |
    • Games
    • |
    • Lottery
    • |
    • Caption contest
    • |
    • Today in history
  • Home
  • |
  • Today's Globe
  • |
  • News
  • |
  • Business
  • |
  • Sports
  • |
  • Lifestyle
  • |
  • A&E
  • |
  • Things to Do
  • |
  • Travel
  • |
  • Cars
  • |
  • Jobs
  • |
  • Real Estate
  • |
  • Local Search
  • Contact Boston.com
  • |
  • Help
  • |
  • Advertise
  • |
  • Work here
  • |
  • Privacy Policy
  • |
  • Your Ad Choices
  • |
  • |
  • Mobile
  • |
  • RSS feeds
  • |
  • Sitemap
  • Contact The Boston Globe
  • |
  • Subscribe
  • |
  • Manage your subscription
  • |
  • Advertise
  • |
  • Boston Globe Insiders
  • |
  • The Boston Globe Gallery
  • |
  • © NY Times Co.