Re: Posey or Battier?
posted at 7/27/2010 7:42 PM EDT
In Response to Re: Posey or Battier?
wayne, wayne, wayne - your record on this thread so far includes two completely irrelevant arguments for Posey, one pathetic attempt to dismiss the fact that Battier out-performed Posey in every way last season, even when their records are minutes-adjusted, and then a major mis-statement of a post I made on a different thread. I'm going to assume that your mis-statement was due to a lack of reading comprehension rather than a deliberate distortion. If you had read the post in question more carefully, you would have seen that I didn't say that Rondo was the best PG in the league. I said that CPaul was the best PG, but that IF CPaul comes back at less than 100% of his pre-injury level, then Rondo would be the best. I based that assessment on a tightly-reasoned argument that included the top four PG efficiency ratings corrected for the defensive abilities of those four players. In addition, you keep throwing arguments into the discussion, and then changing to different arguments when the previous argument is shown to be wrong. Your latest such attempt was the change from attempting to make the case for your PREFERENCE for Posey to a completley unsupported assertion that Battier wouldn't come here. You are just digging a deeper hole, man.
Posted by jerrycole
Okay. So basically you're saying Rondo is better than Deron Williams. Okay, cool.
Too bad you're the ONLY person who believes that.
Honestly, I wouldn't put Rondo over Derrick Rose, my other favorite PG besides Chris Paul, but that's a topic for another debate.
But why so much hate against Posey? Did he take your girlfriend?
Seriously though, Posey was one of my favorite players on the championship squad, the name of this thread is "Posey or Battier", my pick was Posey, so what's the point in having a thread of who you would like, and everyone says the same person?(Battier)
Posey knows the system, Battier is not the player he once was, I've seen all 82 Rockets games.
Posey is MY CHOICE.
Battier is NOT coming here.